Yahoo Groups archive

Elektron Musical Instruments

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:22 UTC

Message

RE: [elektron] OK... Help to make a choice between Rack Attack and MachineDrum

2002-09-10 by RENGA Moreno

First of all, guys... THANK YOU SO MUCH.

It is realy difficult for me to make a choice as i have to make the right
decision.
When i buy a machine, i wish i would never sell it back. Apparently there
are a lot of parameters to edit in the MD. I was fearing that it wasn't the
case.

Thanks again Craz, Kraken and Private-Joy.

Take care you all... and i am happy to say I'M WITH MACHINEDRUM!  =; )
Anybody selling one in Europe???............HA HA HA Loooool... =; D

Moreno


> Moreno,
>
> To try and help with your choice, I'll first give you some
> background info
> on myself. I've been using the Roland TR-Series quite intensively
> for years
> now. Although they're basically just 'preset'-boxes, I like the
> programming, and the hands-on control over virtually every parameter.
> Besides the Roland's, I am a big fan of Old Simmons Drumsynths, which are
> by no means 'preset'-boxes.. and offer a wide variety of sounds
> with a huge
> range of control.
>
> I owned a RackAttack for about two weeks. I bought it because I was
> instantly convinced by its sound. It is powerful, and can really cut
> through a mix like butter. The downside is the control, because
> you hardly
> have any. The well-known Micro-Q interface is just not for me.
> And building
> drumsounds from scratch is not my thing either. At least not by toggling,
> switching and selecting things from cryptic menu's.
>
> I have also had a chance to play with the MD for a couple of hours. And
> again.. the sound blew me away! I had a 909 with me to compare
> the two, but
> the MD was ever so more powerful (but then again... don't be fooled by
> that.. it's how it sounds in the mix that really counts). The MD has a
> full-featured TR-style sequencer (the RA has not). There's more controls
> than on the RA, but there's still a lot of menu's to plough
> through to get
> to all the settings (I guess there's just too many of them.. ).
>
> If it is a staight one-to-one choice between the two.. don't even bother
> about the RackAttack.. and get yourself an MD. But even the MD has some
> downsides to it. Many of which have been discussed on this very
> list already.
>
> Anyway.. I hope my considerations can be of help.
>
> Cheers,
>
> CraZ
>
>
> At 11:49 2002.09.10, you wrote:
> >Hi...
> >Anybody knowing about both machines???
> >
> >I suppose the MachineDrum has a more wild range of sounds thanks to its 4
> >synth architecture. And as gavin Cook said: The MD is more for electro
> >sounds... is this right?
> >Has the MD a Modulation Matrix???
> >If yes... How many Matrix lines???
> >
> >And the Rack Attack is more pure Analog sound right??? As it uses
> >substractive synthesis and common analog waveforms to generate sound.
> >Well i am wondering finaly if the RA can do most of the sounds
> of the MD???
> >
> >so many questions... i know... but because it is an important choice to
> >make.
> >
> >I already have some feedback but not enough...
> >Thank you guys.
> >Take care,
> >Moreno
> >
> >
> >Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
> >ADVERTISEMENT
> ><http://rd.yahoo.com/M=213858.2336340.3766596.2225242/D=egroupweb
/S=1705031959:HM/A=763352/R=0/*http://www.classmates.com/index.tf?s=5085>ca4
19.jpg
>
>Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the
><http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/>Yahoo! Terms of Service.


TonyBlack 100% Pure Acid Techno
http://www.tonyblack.org

The Dutch Synth Forum
http://www.synthforum.nl

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.