A very good read, indeed! > From: "Sascha Franck" <saschafranck@...> > Reply-To: exs-users@yahoogroups.com > Date: Sun, 9 Dec 2001 11:50:28 +0100 > To: <exs-users@yahoogroups.com> > Subject: Re: [exs] HALion vs. EXS, was: Free Spectrasonics library if youcan > figure this out first! > > Arvid Solvang wrote: >> The drum editor in Cubase lets you have all drumtracks inside one >> "matrix/hyperedit" window and alter all of them together inside one window >> while hearing all sounds when you click on them. >> You can also change midichannels program change etc... from that window. >> It's more like an arrangewindow for drums. > > Ok, I agree that for a "one-size-fits-all" Cubases drum editor really isn't > bad. But you can have everything like that too in Logic, using a mapped > instrument. > >> This basically works in Matrix editor for logic too, but if you use one >> EXS24 for kick drum and one EXS for snare etc... (and I do that all the > time >> since we doesn't have multiple outputs on them) you won't hear more than > one >> sampler when you click on a note. This is a major drawback inside Logic at >> the moment. > >> I expect it to be fixed in the future, but as of now; working with > multiple >> samplers inside logic isn't good at all. > > I agree, this is a drawback, but it doesn't have to do with a non-existing > drum editor in Logic but rather with the fact that you can't use multiple > instances of virtual instruments for realtime play right now. > Btw, this is also annoying when you try to do some quick layered sounds - > works a treat with "plain" MIDI instrument but is a defenite no-no with > virtual instruments. > > Jer wrote: >> Right you are. For some reason, I had the impression that hyperedit was > able >> to handle multiple midi channels (don't know why I would think that) > > I know why you would think that - because it indeed does so. In "drum mode" > there's a MIDI Cha. box for each individual note. > >> I do all my drums with the EXS (except in rare >> instances), so I can appreciate the value of you suggestion. I've simply >> been used to living with out it, and it's always been ok with me to deal >> with kicks on one track, snares on another, etc. I'm sure I would make use >> of the feature, however, if it were there. Especially when banging out >> different ideas before laying the tracks down. Actually, I'm really > starting >> to see the light here... Damn, that would be nice! > > I don't exactly think we'll see such a feature in the EXS too early (of > course that would be highly welcomed over here as well), but may I suggest > using one of the several dedicated drum samplers around? As soon as you do a > lot of drum programming you will never ever regret spending a bit of money > on one of them. > Actually, almost all of those are programmed to make drumset editing on the > fly a breeze - this very often is another showstopper with the EXS, just try > to exchange a single snaresound (doesn't even have to be a velo-layered one) > in the EXS, a true pain if you ask me because you allways have to resave the > patch under a new name. > Also, when being in the "banging out different ideas" state of composing, > dedicated drumsamplers defenitely offer better options. For example, N.I.s > Battery and FXpansions DR-008 have a kickass "play in context" feature, > meaning that you can let your sequence playback while scrolling through your > samples. As soon as you "touch" a sample it will be triggered by your > sequence. Unbeatable feature - I couldn't live without that anymore. Also, > all those drum samplers usually give you acess to the most important things > to alter a sample, such as pitch, panning, attack and so on in a very quick > and handy way, so one could forget about the limitation of not having > multiple outputs for a while. > > Regards, > Sascha > > > > To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: > exs-users-unsubscribe@egroups.com > > > > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/ > > >
Message
Re: [exs] HALion vs. EXS, was: Free Spectrasonics library if youcan figure this out first!
2001-12-10 by HELP@MusicBootCamp.com
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.