Some are the same, some are different. I'd say if you have the Protean Drums and XL ROMs you have most of what is in the Vintage, drum-wise, as the Vintage has the fewest drums of the three, many of which are duplicated in the other two. There are some sounds that seem to be unique to the Vintage, though, which I did not expect. Compared to the XL ROM, the Vintage ROM contains the SP-1200, SK-1, and MS-20 sounds from the Protean Drums as well as a few 808 and 909- ish sounds (few of the samples are named anything more descriptive than "Kick 19", and there is no keymap available) that are not in the XL. The acoustic kits (I believe there are two) don't seem to come from either XL or PX. If you want more electronic drum sounds and don't want the (very realistic) acoustic kits of the PX ROM then the Vintage might make sense, but due to the overlap with the XL you'll probably get more mileage out of something like the TSCY ROM, which has lots of 909 samples. For me it was nice to get a few more drum samples to work with, as the primary function of my Command Station is drum programming, but it wasn't a significant factor in my decision to get the ROM, which has other strengths. --- In xl7@yahoogroups.com, "puzzlelounge" <puzzlelounge@y...> wrote: > Robotchas, > > Can you give more details regaring the overlap in the drums, Vintage > Collection vs XL-7? Are the 808 and 909 kits the same, or different? > How about the other Vintage kits? > > Jared >
Message
Re: Vintage Collection ROM Review
2004-05-10 by robotchas
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.