--- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "Nick Carroll" <njcarroll56@y...>
wrote:
>
> --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "edrummin" <jjff@v...> wrote:
> >
> > Greetings edrum brothers,
> > Does anyone know where to get classic songs from ELP,Zep,etc.
> > without drum tracks? I have heard the "Lay it Down" cds but would
> > like some old classics. Also,can the drums on existing albums, I
> > mean cds,(guess I'm showing my age) be taken out by a mix or
> > something? Thank for any info.
>
> I believe a CD burning program like Nero can be used to remove
> selected instruments from tracks. I haven't done so, however.
Hi Nick and edrummin,
Unless I've missed something (always a possibility), extracting
drums, or any other instrument, from a fully mastered stereo
recording is not an easy proposition. If you have the original
multitrack tapes, then you can cut anything that occupies its own
track, but once you get to the final stage, and everything is mixed
into two channels, you're in a pickle. In the higher reaches of
digital manipulation, engineers can tinker with data and make
remarkable changes to an original recording, eliminating noise and
correcting the ravages of time, but deleting one element without
affecting everything else would seem prohibitive. In the early days
of stereo, a lot of popular music was recorded with brickwall pans
that often left the drums on their own channel. Early Beatle albums
were not immune. In that case, it's pretty easy to substitute your
own drumming for Ringo's.
I don't know what the Music Minus One CDs have to offer these days. I
used them to accompany jazz standards on my trombone back in the late
fifties and early sixties. Doesn't the Berkley School of Music have a
bunch of CDs with bass lines for drummers to follow? In terms of the
rock classics, the best that you probably can do is to mine one of
those MIDI sites that has a selection of popular songs and cut the
drum channel. I don't know much about them, but that's what MIDI can
offer. If anyone has other information or suggestions, please post it.
Ed