DTXpress 1 Bass drum trigger problem
2004-05-03 by robert_cathy
Yahoo Groups archive
Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:44 UTC
Thread
2004-05-03 by robert_cathy
Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I am hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger a sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem that I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn and that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? Thanks Robert
2004-05-03 by William Sutherland
Yes, this exact thing happened to me when I was trying to set up the Dtxpress 1 module with my new Hart Dynamics kit. I could not see why it was happening - snare and hi-hat yes, that's not uncommon but there was no physical link between the bass drum and the other pads affected - and I was playing very quietly. In the end it just cured itself - I switched to another kit and changed the pad settings (to DT in my case) and I just noticed it had stopped happening - and I could not recreate the problem thereafter. So yes... but no idea why ! Sorry :-( If you do find out I'd be interested to know also ! :-) William --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "robert_cathy" <robert_cathy@y...> wrote: > Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I am > hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger a > sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem that > I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn and
> that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? > Thanks > Robert
2004-05-03 by William Sutherland
Oops, sorry - just checked back my notes - with me it was the other way around - it was the bass drum that was sounding and the other struck pad not. W. --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "William Sutherland" <ws@l...> wrote: > Yes, this exact thing happened to me when I was trying to set up the > Dtxpress 1 module with my new Hart Dynamics kit. I could not see > why it was happening - snare and hi-hat yes, that's not uncommon but > there was no physical link between the bass drum and the other pads > affected - and I was playing very quietly. > In the end it just cured itself - I switched to another kit and > changed the pad settings (to DT in my case) and I just noticed it > had stopped happening - and I could not recreate the problem > thereafter. > > So yes... but no idea why ! Sorry :-( > > If you do find out I'd be interested to know also ! :-) > > William > > > --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "robert_cathy" <robert_cathy@y...> > wrote: > > Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I > am > > hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger
> a > > sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem > that > > I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn > and > > that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? > > Thanks > > Robert
2004-05-03 by emf
--- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "robert_cathy" <robert_cathy@y...> wrote: > Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I am > hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger a > sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem that > I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn and > that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? Hi Robert, Dropouts aren't terribly unusual. But, as Will's post indicates, the kick pad isn't usually the victim--at least for interactive reasons. When a pad on the rack gets hit, the rack can transmit vibrations to one or more of the other ones, causing a sympathetic reaction. This phenomenon is called crosstalk, and Yamaha has "rejection" settings to minimize it in the trigger menu. Rejection's remedy for a pad firing unintentionally as a result of events on other pads is to mute it unless it is hit with a certain minimum force (the rejection number). "Specific rejection" protects a pad from hits on a certain other pad, normally close to it, in the same manner. "Self-rejection" guards against a pad reacting to itself (double-triggers), usually because gain is too high. If a drummer fails to strike a pad with enough force to circumvent the muting enabled by any of these rejection parameters during another offending event, it won't make any noise. Many dropouts are caused by rejection settings that are too high. By all means, if the kick drum input carries high rejection numbers, reduce them to the point where the offending artifacts disappear. That said, however, the fact that the kick pad isn't on the rack reduces the chances that rejection as a means to defeat crosstalk is the culprit. A high self-rejection is still a possibility, though you would have known if you'd set it, right? One other possibility is that your gain and/or minimum velocity settings aren't optimal. If gain is too low and min.vel. too high, you could get false triggering. It might not happen when you play the kick by itself, but in the heat of battle when your attention is divided, the kick might not be getting the same impact. Try changing the gain and min. vel. settings as indicated. A last resort might be that the something has come loose inside the kick tower. Sometimes resoldering everything can improve response, even if you don't actually see a loose connection somewhere. I hope these suggestions help. Please let us know. If worst comes to worst, are you still under warranty? I should add that if you're using the KP60 kick pad, I'd be far less surprised by your problem than if you were using the the KP65. Ed
2004-05-04 by nugeman2004
--- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "emf" <liberatusvirus@y...> wrote: > --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "robert_cathy" <robert_cathy@y...> > wrote: > > Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I > am > > hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger a > > sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem > that > > I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn > and > > that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? > > Hi Robert, > > Dropouts aren't terribly unusual. But, as Will's post indicates, the > kick pad isn't usually the victim--at least for interactive reasons. > When a pad on the rack gets hit, the rack can transmit vibrations to > one or more of the other ones, causing a sympathetic reaction. This > phenomenon is called crosstalk, and Yamaha has "rejection" settings > to minimize it in the trigger menu. Rejection's remedy for a pad > firing unintentionally as a result of events on other pads is to mute > it unless it is hit with a certain minimum force (the rejection > number). "Specific rejection" protects a pad from hits on a certain > other pad, normally close to it, in the same manner. "Self- rejection" > guards against a pad reacting to itself (double-triggers), usually > because gain is too high. If a drummer fails to strike a pad with > enough force to circumvent the muting enabled by any of these > rejection parameters during another offending event, it won't make > any noise. Many dropouts are caused by rejection settings that are > too high. By all means, if the kick drum input carries high rejection > numbers, reduce them to the point where the offending artifacts > disappear. > > That said, however, the fact that the kick pad isn't on the rack > reduces the chances that rejection as a means to defeat crosstalk is > the culprit. A high self-rejection is still a possibility, though you > would have known if you'd set it, right? One other possibility is > that your gain and/or minimum velocity settings aren't optimal. If > gain is too low and min.vel. too high, you could get false > triggering. It might not happen when you play the kick by itself, but > in the heat of battle when your attention is divided, the kick might > not be getting the same impact. Try changing the gain and min. vel. > settings as indicated. > > A last resort might be that the something has come loose inside the > kick tower. Sometimes resoldering everything can improve response, > even if you don't actually see a loose connection somewhere. > > I hope these suggestions help. Please let us know. If worst comes to > worst, are you still under warranty? I should add that if you're > using the KP60 kick pad, I'd be far less surprised by your problem > than if you were using the the KP65. > > Ed I too, have the same issue! when playing as Ed said "heat of the battle" and do an accent of snare and cymbbal, the kick almost always will not sound, And I am certainly kicking it! I have tried it with the tower yammy set up , as well as a pintech trigger,the small cylindrical one (scientific,no?) and the results are about the same. I did have some issues with the yammy stand up trigger,and had to disassemble and solder the jack terminals back solidly to the pc board...that cured the hit/no sound, but not the no kick response when hitting cymbal(any) and or cymbal/snare /kick...any ideas Ed? kb
2004-05-04 by emf
--- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "nugeman2004" <kbhammerken@g...> wrote: > the rim hits were, for the most part,always consistent.I have used the kit for about a year,and have played several gigs, as well as a lot of recording time. It seems that if I play a busy passage, the center,which I have set up to be a different,similar voice ,it will react at most times ok. But if I do the same on the rim,such as a quick burst of single hits, it will almost always only respond to half(or less) of the contact. kb, If you're not getting the response from the rim that you used to get, some kind of deterioration might be indicated. But I'm not sure that the rim switch is fast enough to register the kind of fast sticking that you'd do on the head proper. It's built more for cross-stick and rimshot transients. Hitting the switch is like taking an indirect route to the piezo at the center; it's one step removed. > I too, have the same issue! when playing as Ed said "heat of the > battle" and do an accent of snare and cymbbal, the kick almost always > will not sound, And I am certainly kicking it! I have tried it with > the tower yammy set up , as well as a pintech trigger,the small > cylindrical one (scientific,no?) and the results are about the same. > I did have some issues with the yammy stand up trigger,and had to > disassemble and solder the jack terminals back solidly to the pc > board...that cured the hit/no sound, but not the no kick response > when hitting cymbal(any) and or cymbal/snare /kick...any ideas Ed? I assume that you're talking about the KP60 and the Pintech Ergokik. The KP60 didn't prove to be a terribly reliable trigger. The archives are riddled with people complaining about dropouts as well as double triggers. Four years ago, Yamaha sent me two of them to try, and both exhibited the same tendencies. I re-soldered and tweaked until I was blue in the face without any success. But in my case, and many others, the troubles were endemic to the kick pad itself; they were coincidental with other events on the kit. From what I gather lately, the KP65 has not exhibited this bad behavior. Nor have I heard about it with the Pintech. If raising the gain and lowering the rejection of the kick don't improve its response when you're hitting other pads, the only other cause of sound truncation that comes to mind is the module reaching its processing limit--32 voice polyphony. Even though this phenomenon is definitely tied to the heat of battle, it Usually won't happen unless you're playing along with prerecorded songs on layered pads with long decay times, etc. (make sure that Key Assign is set to mono). I suppose that the module could suffer from other kinds of overload, but I'm not aware of them. I can say with some confidence, however, that it does not pay to drive these kits too hard with brute force. Rule of thumb: Learn to play e-drums with some restraint, and let the module do the work of creating volume. I suppose you could keep experimenting with hitting individual pads and the kick at the same time to see if you can reproduce the problem with any regularity and narrow it down with the process of elimination. You could also test different pad-type settings for better triggering. That's all that occurs to me at the moment. Ed
2004-05-04 by rdamon@mckinney-usa.com
Just to throw out a quick thought. The KP65 piezo, unlike the PCY/TP pads has a substantial amount of pading between the surface of the rubber and the actual piezo. On the PCY, the piezo has a thin layer of plastic and rubber pading between it and the striking surface, nothing to temp/permanantly deform to any degree. On the TP the piezo has a metal plate and a thin layer of rubber pading between it and the striking surface, again nothing to temp/permanantly deform to any degree. But on the KP65 there is a heavy rubber cover that is not bonded to anything and behind it is a thick layer of foam that is bonded to the metal plate that secures the piezo. After repeated heavy blows to the KP65 the following could and will occur: The outer rubber cover could be pulling away from the foam as it temp. stretches from repeated strikes. The thick foam behind the pad could be compressing and not expanding back out quick enough to make contact with the outer rubber pad. I used to leave my foot on the pedal with the felt beater pressed against the rubber pad between beats and would end up having similair missed beats. Since I stopped leaving the beater pressed against the rubber pad, the problem has disappeared for me. I wonder if putting some adhesive between the rubber pad and the foam to bind them together would help? The other possibility is simply a loose connection. Other things to look at are the settings such as the curves; normal, loud1, loud2, hard1, hard2 and Self rej is set to a low number. OGD _____
From: nugeman2004 Sent: Monday, May 03, 2004 9:49 PM To: DTXpress@yahoogroups.com Subject: [DTXpress] Re: DTXpress 1 Bass drum trigger problem --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "emf" <liberatusvirus@y...> wrote: > --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "robert_cathy" <robert_cathy@y...> > wrote: > > Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I > am > > hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger a > > sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem > that > > I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn > and > > that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? > > Hi Robert, > > Dropouts aren't terribly unusual. But, as Will's post indicates, the > kick pad isn't usually the victim--at least for interactive reasons. > When a pad on the rack gets hit, the rack can transmit vibrations to > one or more of the other ones, causing a sympathetic reaction. This > phenomenon is called crosstalk, and Yamaha has "rejection" settings > to minimize it in the trigger menu. Rejection's remedy for a pad > firing unintentionally as a result of events on other pads is to mute > it unless it is hit with a certain minimum force (the rejection > number). "Specific rejection" protects a pad from hits on a certain > other pad, normally close to it, in the same manner. "Self- rejection" > guards against a pad reacting to itself (double-triggers), usually > because gain is too high. If a drummer fails to strike a pad with > enough force to circumvent the muting enabled by any of these > rejection parameters during another offending event, it won't make > any noise. Many dropouts are caused by rejection settings that are > too high. By all means, if the kick drum input carries high rejection > numbers, reduce them to the point where the offending artifacts > disappear. > > That said, however, the fact that the kick pad isn't on the rack > reduces the chances that rejection as a means to defeat crosstalk is > the culprit. A high self-rejection is still a possibility, though you > would have known if you'd set it, right? One other possibility is > that your gain and/or minimum velocity settings aren't optimal. If > gain is too low and min.vel. too high, you could get false > triggering. It might not happen when you play the kick by itself, but > in the heat of battle when your attention is divided, the kick might > not be getting the same impact. Try changing the gain and min. vel. > settings as indicated. > > A last resort might be that the something has come loose inside the > kick tower. Sometimes resoldering everything can improve response, > even if you don't actually see a loose connection somewhere. > > I hope these suggestions help. Please let us know. If worst comes to > worst, are you still under warranty? I should add that if you're > using the KP60 kick pad, I'd be far less surprised by your problem > than if you were using the the KP65. > > Ed I too, have the same issue! when playing as Ed said "heat of the battle" and do an accent of snare and cymbbal, the kick almost always will not sound, And I am certainly kicking it! I have tried it with the tower yammy set up , as well as a pintech trigger,the small cylindrical one (scientific,no?) and the results are about the same. I did have some issues with the yammy stand up trigger,and had to disassemble and solder the jack terminals back solidly to the pc board...that cured the hit/no sound, but not the no kick response when hitting cymbal(any) and or cymbal/snare /kick...any ideas Ed? kb ************************************************************************** The information transmitted herewith is sensitive information intended only for use to the individual or entity to which it is addressed. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any review, retransmission, dissemination, distribution, copying or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from your computer. ______________________________________________________________________ This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email Security System. For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email ______________________________________________________________________
2004-05-26 by slivjakm
I'm having a related problem with my kick drum pad but I'm not sure it's the same thing. The drummer in my band is a bit heavy-footed and after about a year of no problems, it seems the pad doesn't respond to hard kicks. A moderate kick will trigger OK, but when he plays it hard there are random non-triggers (I would have thought you would need increasing pressure trigger something that has been stretched out?). I haven't taken it apart (any direction there would be appreciated) and I'm not even sure what the warranty is on these drums. Any help is greatly welcomed- thanks. Mark --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, rdamon@m... wrote: > Just to throw out a quick thought. The KP65 piezo, unlike the PCY/TP pads > has a substantial amount of pading between the surface of the rubber and the > actual piezo. > > On the PCY, the piezo has a thin layer of plastic and rubber pading between > it and the striking surface, nothing to temp/permanantly deform to any > degree. On the TP the piezo has a metal plate and a thin layer of rubber > pading between it and the striking surface, again nothing to > temp/permanantly deform to any degree. > > But on the KP65 there is a heavy rubber cover that is not bonded to anything > and behind it is a thick layer of foam that is bonded to the metal plate > that secures the piezo. After repeated heavy blows to the KP65 the following > could and will occur: > > The outer rubber cover could be pulling away from the foam as it temp. > stretches from repeated strikes. > The thick foam behind the pad could be compressing and not expanding back > out quick enough to make contact with the outer rubber pad. > > I used to leave my foot on the pedal with the felt beater pressed against > the rubber pad between beats and would end up having similair missed beats. > Since I stopped leaving the beater pressed against the rubber pad, the > problem has disappeared for me. > > I wonder if putting some adhesive between the rubber pad and the foam to > bind them together would help? > > The other possibility is simply a loose connection. > > Other things to look at are the settings such as the curves; normal, loud1, > loud2, hard1, hard2 and Self rej is set to a low number. > > > OGD > > _____ > > From: nugeman2004 Sent: Monday, May 03, 2004 9:49 PM > To: DTXpress@yahoogroups.com > Subject: [DTXpress] Re: DTXpress 1 Bass drum trigger problem > > > --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "emf" <liberatusvirus@y...> wrote: > > --- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "robert_cathy" <robert_cathy@y...> > > wrote: > > > Has anyone heard of this problem, sometimes but not always when I > > am > > > hitting a snare, cymbal or highhat, the bass drum doesn't trigger > a > > > sound even thought it is being hit? It is a intermitten problem > > that > > > I have to listen closely to hear. My daughter is trying to learn > > and > > > that how I found it. Any ideas? Any solutions? > > > > Hi Robert, > > > > Dropouts aren't terribly unusual. But, as Will's post indicates, > the > > kick pad isn't usually the victim--at least for interactive > reasons. > > When a pad on the rack gets hit, the rack can transmit vibrations > to > > one or more of the other ones, causing a sympathetic reaction. This > > phenomenon is called crosstalk, and Yamaha has "rejection" settings > > to minimize it in the trigger menu. Rejection's remedy for a pad > > firing unintentionally as a result of events on other pads is to > mute > > it unless it is hit with a certain minimum force (the rejection > > number). "Specific rejection" protects a pad from hits on a certain > > other pad, normally close to it, in the same manner. "Self- > rejection" > > guards against a pad reacting to itself (double-triggers), usually > > because gain is too high. If a drummer fails to strike a pad with > > enough force to circumvent the muting enabled by any of these > > rejection parameters during another offending event, it won't make > > any noise. Many dropouts are caused by rejection settings that are > > too high. By all means, if the kick drum input carries high > rejection > > numbers, reduce them to the point where the offending artifacts > > disappear. > > > > That said, however, the fact that the kick pad isn't on the rack > > reduces the chances that rejection as a means to defeat crosstalk > is > > the culprit. A high self-rejection is still a possibility, though > you > > would have known if you'd set it, right? One other possibility is > > that your gain and/or minimum velocity settings aren't optimal. If > > gain is too low and min.vel. too high, you could get false > > triggering. It might not happen when you play the kick by itself, > but > > in the heat of battle when your attention is divided, the kick > might > > not be getting the same impact. Try changing the gain and min. vel. > > settings as indicated. > > > > A last resort might be that the something has come loose inside the > > kick tower. Sometimes resoldering everything can improve response, > > even if you don't actually see a loose connection somewhere. > > > > I hope these suggestions help. Please let us know. If worst comes > to > > worst, are you still under warranty? I should add that if you're > > using the KP60 kick pad, I'd be far less surprised by your problem > > than if you were using the the KP65. > > > > Ed > I too, have the same issue! when playing as Ed said "heat of the > battle" and do an accent of snare and cymbbal, the kick almost always > will not sound, And I am certainly kicking it! I have tried it with > the tower yammy set up , as well as a pintech trigger,the small > cylindrical one (scientific,no?) and the results are about the same. > I did have some issues with the yammy stand up trigger,and had to > disassemble and solder the jack terminals back solidly to the pc > board...that cured the hit/no sound, but not the no kick response > when hitting cymbal(any) and or cymbal/snare /kick...any ideas Ed? kb > > > > > ********************************************************************* ***** > The information transmitted herewith is sensitive information intended only > for use to the individual or entity to which it is addressed. If the reader > of this message is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that > any review, retransmission, dissemination, distribution, copying or other > use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information is > strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, > please contact the sender and delete the material from your computer. > > > _____________________________________________________________________ _ > This email has been scanned by the MessageLabs Email Security System. > For more information please visit http://www.messagelabs.com/email > _____________________________________________________________________ _
2004-05-26 by emf
--- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "slivjakm" <mjsliv@h...> wrote: > I'm having a related problem with my kick drum pad but I'm not sure > it's the same thing. The drummer in my band is a bit heavy-footed > and after about a year of no problems, it seems the pad doesn't > respond to hard kicks. A moderate kick will trigger OK, but when he > plays it hard there are random non-triggers (I would have thought > you would need increasing pressure trigger something that has been > stretched out?). I haven't taken it apart (any direction there would > be appreciated) and I'm not even sure what the warranty is on these > drums. Any help is greatly welcomed- thanks. Hi Mark, Is the offending kick pad a KP60 that you bought secondhand? If so, forget about a warranty; it must be three or four years old. I long ago threw logic out the window with that particular pad; relatively speaking, yours seems to have led a long life; not too many KP60s lasted that long. I've opened up a few of them looking for why they were misbehaving and never found an obvious reason. In your case, you'd be lucky if the problem were simply a matter of assigning a new pad type. But I don't think so. My guess is that some connection is loose on the board, whether visible or not. When you strike the pad moderately, the connection remains generally stable, but when you hammer it hard, it gets disrupted. The best you can do might be to open it up--which is simply a matter of unscrewing the plate and pulling the elements apart--check the wires and resolder everything regardless of appearances. You might also spray some WD-40 into the jack and on the connector. You'll be surprised how uncomplicated the insides are. If you're unable to improve triggering and have to buy another kick pad, you'll find the new one, whatever it is, superior in every way. That's all that occurs to me. Please feel free to get a second opinion. Ed
2004-05-26 by slivjakm
Ed: Thanks for the reply. I bought the set new last year (less than a year ago, so I'm hoping the warranty will cover it), the DTXpress II, so it would be the kick pad that shipped with that. Your explanation seems logical. I'll try the simple (WD-40) before I tinker with it and void the warranty. Never dealt with Yamaha before, we'll see how they are. Mark > > Hi Mark, > > Is the offending kick pad a KP60 that you bought secondhand? If so, > forget about a warranty; it must be three or four years old. I long > ago threw logic out the window with that particular pad; relatively > speaking, yours seems to have led a long life; not too many KP60s > lasted that long. I've opened up a few of them looking for why they > were misbehaving and never found an obvious reason. In your case, > you'd be lucky if the problem were simply a matter of assigning a new > pad type. But I don't think so. My guess is that some connection is > loose on the board, whether visible or not. When you strike the pad > moderately, the connection remains generally stable, but when you > hammer it hard, it gets disrupted. The best you can do might be to > open it up--which is simply a matter of unscrewing the plate and > pulling the elements apart--check the wires and resolder everything > regardless of appearances. You might also spray some WD-40 into the > jack and on the connector. You'll be surprised how uncomplicated the > insides are. If you're unable to improve triggering and have to buy > another kick pad, you'll find the new one, whatever it is, superior > in every way. That's all that occurs to me. Please feel free to get a
> second opinion. > > Ed
2004-05-26 by emf
--- In DTXpress@yahoogroups.com, "slivjakm" <mjsliv@h...> wrote: > Thanks for the reply. I bought the set new last year (less than a > year ago, so I'm hoping the warranty will cover it), the DTXpress > II, so it would be the kick pad that shipped with that. Your > explanation seems logical. I'll try the simple (WD-40) before I > tinker with it and void the warranty. Never dealt with Yamaha > before, we'll see how they are. Mark, I must have missed that you had a KP65. My guess about the problem still holds, but OGD's description of the insides in a previous post supervenes. If you do open it up, check the foam behind the rubber to make sure that it hasn't seriously deteriorated. Incidentally, Yamaha has always been helpful about such things. We've had a good relationship with them for a long time. Try calling 1-888-892-6242 for Martin Arroyo of customer support, or Dave Ksycki (dkyscki@...), who heads customer support, especially with MIDI. Tell them that the DTXpress Group sent you. Ed