Bc2000 (for the BCF2000 & BCR2000) group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

Bc2000 (for the BCF2000 & BCR2000)

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:16 UTC

Thread

BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-08 by Dave Watkinson

Hey guys

I've been using my BCR2000 with REAPER and AmbiLoop for a couple of years now. Earlier this week I thought I'd try configuring it as a control surface. Everything went well and it worked first time :)

And so a day or so later, the BCR just stopped sending any MIDI. The LEDs are lighting when I turn knobs, push buttons, but my MIDI interface isn't registering anything. I've tried setting it up as a MIDI device, as a control surface (I tried both the BCR and the BCF options). I've tried it with another computer & MIDI interface and it's the same.

MIDI coming in to the unit appears to be OK, because doing anything inside the software causes the LEDs to flash on the BCR. I should probably also mention that I can't get the thing to install in USB mode any more. It used to be OK but or some reason it's seemingly stopped being able to use USB. The Behringer installer times out at the "please connect your device" step, and Windows just says the device failed to start / wasn't recognized. BCManager can't detect it either :(

Is it time for me to look at getting a new BCR? :'-(

Thanks in advance!
Dave

Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-12 by Mark v.d. Berg

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, Dave Watkinson <dave422x@...> wrote:
> MIDI coming in to the unit appears to be OK, because doing anything inside
> the software causes the LEDs to flash on the BCR. I should probably also
> mention that I can't get the thing to install in USB mode any more. It used
> to be OK but or some reason it's seemingly stopped being able to use USB.
> The Behringer installer times out at the "please connect your device" step,
> and Windows just says the device failed to start / wasn't recognized.
> BCManager can't detect it either :(

This does sound as if the USB controller on your BCR is defective, although you should make absolutely sure that it's not a software problem.
This issue has come up before in this group - search the message archive.
You might also want to look at the BC Manager Manual, section 24, question 42.

Maybe a stupid question: are you sure your USB cable is OK?

Hope this helps,
Mark.

RE: [bc2000] Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-12 by dave watkinson

Hi Mark, thanks for your reply.

I reconnected the BCR to my MIDI interface and put it into S3 mode. BC Manager can't detect it. The MIDI interfaces I've tried are the same make & model; they're the type where there's a USB connector on one end and a pair of MIDI DIN connectors on the other. The connector that says "Out" goes to the BCR's In and likewise the connector's In goes to the BCR's Out. This is the way I had it working for the last few years.

Despite the lack of BCR detection (I disabled all my other USB / MIDI devices) I tried to open the Behringer default sysex file in BC Manager, and was greeted by this message:

Error: MIDI system exclusive error
Wrong command
Send Memory ($34)
This may be the result of a feedback loop
Message 1

When I'm running REAPER, the MIDI interface shows MIDI activity when I do anything transport or song position related (mouse clicks, pressing space, that kind of thing) and the BCR's MIDI In and MIDI A LEDs light up momentarily too. No MIDI data seems to be making it out of the BCR; the BCR LEDs (both A and B) *do* light when I move any controls, but the MIDI indicator on the interface *doesn't* show any sign of life.

I might mention that this BCR has been with me for over 10 years and has travelled from the UK to the US, so I guess it might just be old...

Thanks again!

Dave


To: bc2000@yahoogroups.com
From: markwinvdb@...
Date: Wed, 12 Dec 2012 07:03:40 +0000
Subject: [bc2000] Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, Dave Watkinson wrote:
>; MIDI coming in to the unit appears to be OK, because doing anything inside
> the software causes the LEDs to flash on the BCR. I should probably also
> mention that I can't get the thing to install in USB mode any more. It used
> to be OK but or some reason it's seemingly stopped being able to use USB.
> The Behringer installer times out at the "please connect your device" step,
> and Windows just says the device failed to start / wasn't recognized.
> BCManager can't detect it either :(

This does sound as if the USB controller on your BCR is defective, although you should make absolutely sure that it's not a software problem.
This issue has come up before in this group - search the message archive.
You might also want to look at the BC Manager Manual, section 24, question 42.

Maybe a stupid question: are you sure your USB cable is OK?

Hope this helps,
Mark.


Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-13 by Mark v.d. Berg

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, dave watkinson <dave422x@...> wrote:
> I reconnected the BCR to my MIDI interface and put it into S3 mode. BC Manager can't detect it.

In mode S-3 anything received at the BCR's MIDI IN is directly routed to the BCR's MIDI OUT A.

So in S-3 you shouldn't use MIDI OUT A in a bidirectional setup with your computer; instead, you should use MIDI OUT B.

Alternatively, use MIDI OUT A under S-4.
(MIDI IN is routed to MIDI OUT B in this case.)

> Despite the lack of BCR detection (I disabled all my other USB / MIDI devices) I tried to open the Behringer default sysex file in BC Manager, and was greeted by this message:
> Error: MIDI system exclusive error
> Wrong command
> Send Memory ($34)
> This may be the result of a feedback loop
> Message 1

This is in line with what I wrote above: in S-3, BC Manager gets any message it sends to the BCR's MIDI IN straight back from MIDI OUT A.

Incidentally, the "Send Memory ($34)" messages contain BCR firmware data: if the BCR shows "1.10" upon power-up, there is no need whatsoever to try to update its firmware. (In fact, it's a bit dangerous.)

Hope this helps,
Mark.

[bc2000] Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-15 by dave watkinson

Well, your test WORKED!!

Still nothing in the computer though. I have tried the auto-MIDI-input detection in both REAPER and eDrum MIDI Mapper and neither seems to be receiving anything.

Since I started this thread I have reinstalled Windows (7), I've tried the interface in different USB ports (both on and off my powered hub), and as I said in the first post - I bought another MIDI interface because that's what I thought had broken. I run REAPER in portable mode and so have tried a new install in a separate directory, just in case my preferences had messed something up, but still no MIDI seems to be making it into the computer.

I do have another MIDI interface. It's a 256 channel Yamaha from about a thousand years ago. It seems to work fine with the MIDI out, going into the computer. I only have one MIDI cable available to test with, but it looks like my BCR is NOT broken!! :-)

So now I guess I have two possibly-broken MIDI interfaces. I don't know if the first one broke and the second was faulty, or if some funky Windows update made both of them stop working. What I do know is that I need to get a new USB cable (I had to borrow one from another device to test the Yamaha) and a pair of MIDI cables.

Thanks again Mark, for sticking with it... I probably would have thrown the BCR away! :-)

I'll report back once I get new cables.

Cheers!!

To: bc2000@yahoogroups.com
From: markwinvdb@...
Date: Sat, 15 Dec 2012 10:38:06 +0000
Subject: [bc2000] Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, dave watkinson wrote:
> Looks like it's time to replace it :'-(

In any case it seems that the USB controller on your BCR is defective.
This isn't unheard of: it has happened to other people, including me!
However, what I've never heard before is that ADDITIONALLY the BCR's standard MIDI connections no longer seem to work properly either.

I've reread your earlier posts: if I understand you correctly, in S-3/4 your BCR's I/O LEDs do blink, but your MIDI interface doesn't (seem to) register anything coming out of the BCR.

As a final test of the state of your BCR's MIDI I/O handling, you might try to make the BCR send a Program Change (PC) message to itself, to which it should respond by changing to a different preset:

Switch off the BCR, disconnect all cables except the power cable, and connect a MIDI cable from MIDI OUT A to MIDI IN. (Of course you should be absolutely sure that this MIDI cable itself is OK!)

Then, while holding the STORE and EXIT buttons, switch the BCR on by pressing the POWER button and keep STORE and EXIT pressed until the display has gone from "1.10" via "Init" to "P- 1" (or any other preset number).

Then go to "EG" (Global Setup) by holding EDIT and pressing STORE.
Make the following settings:
Push encoder 1: S-4.
Push encoder 2: Ch 1.
Press EXIT.

Then hold EDIT and press the button immediately below push encoder 1: the display should show "b 33".
Make the following settings:
Push encoder 1: PC
Push encoder 2: Ch 1 (this should be the default, actually)
Push encoder 3 and 4: off (=defaults)
Push encoder 5: any number from 0-31 EXCEPT the number of the current preset minus one; so if you're in preset 1 ("P- 1"), the value entered here can be 1-31 (indicating presets 2-32), but not 0 (because that stands for preset 1 itself). Perhaps the easiest value to enter is the current preset number ITSELF, because that amounts to the next preset; so if you're in "P- 1", I recommend selecting "1" here, which indicates a jump to preset 2.
Push encoder 6: toff (=default)
Press EXIT.
Press STORE twice.

Then comes the moment of truth:
Press the button immediately below push encoder 1 (button 33):
The MIDI IN, A and B LEDs should all flash and the display should switch to the preset defined in the button's PC message, so e.g. from "P- 1" to "P- 2".

If this doesn't work as described above, there is indeed a fault in your BCR's MIDI I/O hardware, and it seems indeed time for a replacement.
If this does work, we can discuss further.

Good luck!
Mark.


Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-16 by Mark v.d. Berg

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, dave watkinson <dave422x@...> wrote:
> Well, your test WORKED!!

Amazing! I didn't think it would work, but rereading your posts it struck me that all the BCR's MIDI I/O LEDs still seemed to work, and it seemed a bit unlikely that these LEDs would "lie".

> Still nothing in the computer though. I have tried the auto-MIDI-input detection in both REAPER and eDrum MIDI Mapper and neither seems to be receiving anything.

One (not necessairly good...) piece of advice:
if I were you, I would leave Reaper and the BCR out of the equation until I've established working MIDI input and output ports (i.e. device drivers) for the MIDI interface(s).
I would test these I/O ports by MIDI Tools.
Maybe you can set up a loop from an interface's output to its input by means of your MIDI cable, just like you've done with the BCR: then you can send something from MIDI Tools (e.g. note or control messages) and see if these messages come back to MIDI Tools.

Hope this helps,
Mark.

RE: [bc2000] Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-21 by dave watkinson

Well I bought a pair of MIDI cables and a new USB A-to-B cable. I tried the USB cable with the BCR in all of its USB modes and it sure does look like USB capabilities are no longer working.

I connected the MIDI cables to the BCR and to the old Yamaha MIDI interface. Communication with REAPER is working on the BCF setting, but not on the BCR setting. I'm also getting some bidirectional communication (Solo and Mute, specificlaly). This is good news!!! :-) "Normal" MIDI control (ie: not set up as a control surface) works fine too :-)

This also seems to confirm that both my original all-in-one-cable USB-to-MIDI adapter did indeed break, and also that the replacement was partially dead-on-arrival. I may indeed so some tests with MIDI Tools on these adapters when I find some free time. For now, though, I'm back up and running.

Thanks again Mark for helping me with this. If I had decided to replace the BCR you would have saved me $100+, and so a small donation to your Mountain Utilities page will be forthcoming.

Merry Christmas and THANKS again!



To: bc2000@yahoogroups.com
From: markwinvdb@hetnet.nl
Date: Sun, 16 Dec 2012 16:22:31 +0000
Subject: [bc2000] Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, dave watkinson wrote:
> Well, your test WORKED!!

Amazing! I didn't think it would work, but rereading your posts it struck me that all the BCR's MIDI I/O LEDs still seemed to work, and it seemed a bit unlikely that these LEDs would "lie".

> Still nothing in the computer though. I have tried the auto-MIDI-input detection in both REAPER and eDrum MIDI Mapper and neither seems to be receiving anything.

One (not necessairly good...) piece of advice:
if I were you, I would leave Reaper and the BCR out of the equation until I've established working MIDI input and output ports (i.e. device drivers) for the MIDI interface(s).
I would test these I/O ports by MIDI Tools.
Maybe you can set up a loop from an interface's output to its input by means of your MIDI cable, just like you've done with the BCR: then you can send something from MIDI Tools (e.g. note or control messages) and see if these messages come back to MIDI Tools.

Hope this helps,
Mark.


Re: BCR2000 no longer sending MIDI?

2012-12-24 by Mark v.d. Berg

--- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com, dave watkinson <dave422x@...> wrote:
> I tried the USB cable with the BCR in all of its USB modes and it sure does look like USB capabilities are no longer working.

Pity. From your very first report it already looked like this, but your further problems in the S-modes confused the situation a lot.

I think over the years I've heard from about five other people with the same problem, and I've had it too:
My first BCR had a USB controller that worked erratically from the moment I bought it, but it took me almost a year to conclude that it WAS really faulty; luckily I was still in my warranty period then, so the shop gave me a free replacement.

> I connected the MIDI cables to the BCR and to the old Yamaha MIDI interface. Communication with REAPER is working on the BCF setting, but not on the BCR setting.

Strange...
Since I'm not a Reaper user, I don't know how Reaper uses the BCR, but in any case this seems like a software/preset problem that can be solved.

> This also seems to confirm that both my original all-in-one-cable USB-to-MIDI adapter did indeed break, and also that the replacement was partially dead-on-arrival.

Dear oh dear - no wonder we had so much trouble figuring things out...
 
> so a small donation to your Mountain Utilities page will be forthcoming.

Yes, I've received your "small" donation: thank you very much!

> Merry Christmas and THANKS again!

Merry Christmas to you too (and everyone else in this group)!
Mark.

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.